Ducted Heating vs. Split System Which One Should You Choose?

If you are checking out a new heating system for warmth and comfort during the long winter months, which one should you choose? Around Melbourne, ducted heating and ductless (split) systems are incredibly popular. As each heating system has its advantages and disadvantages, one system isn’t better than the other. So, let’s solve this selection dilemma for you.

Homeowners in Melbourne often have to choose between gas ducted heating and split system as these two are the most efficient heating solutions available on the market. The answer to the question “which one of these heating systems is better” is often determined by individual circumstances. However, you still have to consider some key aspects before making a decision.

Ducted Heating vs. Split System – What’s The Difference?

A ducted heating system runs either on gas or LPG (less commonly) and uses a core central heating unit. It draws in cold air inside the house and heats the air by passing it over a heat exchanger before pumping the warm air back via ducts and outlets. Read this informative piece on what is gas ducted heating to know more about the heating system.

In contrast, a split system uses an indoor wall unit connected with an outdoor unit. The heat pump runs in reverse to blow warm air around the room. These heating systems are beautifully efficient when it comes to providing consistent warmth in both small and large living areas.

Why Choose Ducted Heating?

A ducted heating system is a much better choice if you are looking for a whole-home heating and cooling solution for the cost of one unit. Opting for this system also makes a lot of sense if you already have ductwork installed or have a large house. Here are a few other reasons why you should consider a gas ducted heating system:

REASON #1: A Cost-Effective Heating Solution

Gas ducted heating systems are cost-effective because of one obvious reason: the use of gas. Given that gas is cheaper than electricity, this heating system can efficiently warm up your place without high-energy bills.

REASON #2: Silent Operation

One of the key advantages of these heating systems is that the inner unit is tucked away out of sight, making it unnoticeable. Unlike split systems that may appear bulky, this system silently does an excellent heating job.

REASON #3: Year-Round Comfort

Gas ducted heating systems are great for the winter months, and add-on cooling makes them provide comfort in the summer months as well. Most importantly, you will not look for a separate cooling solution as it will use the existing ducts to distribute cool air throughout your home equally.

REASON #4: Complete Temperature Control

Ducted heating presents a precise solution to keeping the temperature in your home exactly the way you like it. Some gas heating systems can be controlled via the internet connectivity, so you can turn on the system before coming back to your home.

Drawbacks of Ducted Heating System

One of the most noticeable drawbacks is the high upfront cost, new system, and installation costs. There is a risk of carbon monoxide poisoning if the system is malfunctioning or left un-serviced for too long. The ductwork can become a major source of pollutants without regular duct cleaning. In fact, the ductwork can become a breeding ground for bacteria, algae, mould, and fungi without regular cleaning.

To know more about the pros and cons of a gas ducted heating system, please click here.

Why Choose Ductless Split System?

A split system is ideal if you have a smaller property and there’s no room for ductwork or looking to control temperatures in individual rooms. Here are a few other reasons why a split system is a better choice:

REASON #1: Quick and Hassle-Free Installation

A split system is far less invasive to install than a ducted heating system. It is because installing this heating system requires coupling of the outdoor and indoor units with only a 3-inch hole through the wall.

REASON #2: An Economical Heating Solution

A split system is an affordable heating solution, both initially and in terms of running costs. As you will require one of two of these systems to heat up specific rooms in the house, it will cost you less than a ducted heating system. However, it could be a costly option if you install several split systems in the house. Read this informative piece on how much it costs to run ducted heating.

REASON #3: Increased Energy Efficiency

Ducted heating systems tend to lose energy because heat often dissipates through leaky ducts. This is not an issue with split systems as they don’t require ductwork. In addition, as traditional ducted gas heating systems turn either on or off, these units can slow down or speed up depending on the system heating requirements. This, in return, saves the system from consuming a lot of energy.

REASON #4: Improved Air Quality

Allergens and pollutants in the air can have a detrimental effect on our health. The split system does not use ductwork, so it effectively provides comprehensive filtration to improve indoor air quality.

REASON #5: Minimal Maintenance

With a few running parts compared to a ducted heating system, split systems require minimal maintenance. Only the filters have to be regularly cleaned along with periodic split system service (once a year).

The Drawback of Split System

One of the major drawbacks of these heating systems is that some homeowners find it inadequate for their heating needs. If you install a powerful split system, it could warm up the place properly. However, installing a small-sized unit could lead to the unit overworking or even breaking down.

Another major drawback is the aesthetic appeal, which some homeowners find disturbing as it does use up wall space. However, these units come in different colours and designs to complement the interior décor of the home.

Ducted Heating vs. Split System: Which One Is Better?

A ducted heating system offers good airflow, humidity control, filtration, and less carbon footprint.  On the other hand, a split system has a lower installation and running cost, consistent heat, and easy maintenance. Both systems have their pros and cons, and the answer to which one is the most effective depends entirely on your heating requirements.

In case you need more guidance or have any queries related to which system could be more suitable, please feel free to contact us. Our experts can help you make an educated decision.

A ONE-STOP SOLUTION For All Your Heating & Cooling Needs